Okay Temiz


or go back to the index page
of Music with sitar & Indian influences
or go back to general index page
All links updated 2004-10-18
new info at 2004-11-29


private The Udhav Shinde Trio (IND/(US/UK)/B,2003)*°°

This is an Antwerp based group of Indian pakhawaj player (-a tall form of tabla-) Udhav Shinde who usually lives and stays in India, Judy Rust, an American born singer for the opera choir in Antwerp and Daniel McBrearty, originally from Wales, a sax player who’s heavily influenced by the American tradition, like Johnny Hodges, Coleman Hawkins and Sidney Bechet. His sax works perfectly well in mood with the Indian modes. In this way it’s comparable to what clarinet playerTony Scott was doing with Colin Walcott, for instance on his “Music for meditations”, even when the sax still is different from style.
Judy, also the manager of the group, the female voice however I didn't like so much. Even when classical trained, singing in the opera choir, her voice doesn’t carry much, has a fragility in the voice which, in combination with the loose pronunciations of Indian, with as result weakly dancing notes, for these reasons remind me also of hippie self-assuredness, of local western Hare Krishna dreamers, or of New Age believers, who all when singing give only themselves the impression they are in the spirit of things because they want to believe in it for themselves, all without enough caretaking to know what the magical ancient language of Sanskrit or any of the developed languages out of it really needs technically to create any fundament for singing this. In her biography it says “Having practiced mantra and meditation for many years” is another remark that often made my hairs rise, because nowadays everybody think they can suddenly become somebody “spiritual” above the ordinary, just by following some rich people fast-becoming-knowledgeable course. BUT never the less I must add some words of Judy explaining what she does here, which makes sense :
"These (songs) are Marathi bhajans, devotional songs which were written by poet-saints of Maharashtra who were ordinary people, merchants, farmers, etc. They were written for ordinary people to sing in their own language in an informal setting, as a part of everyday life. The texts are often about the personal relationship of an individual with a deity. This is in contrast to the tradition of Brahman priests as the only ones who could have access to God.  Tukaram, the composer of thousands of bhajans and Khela Mandiyela and Kaise Jaina on this CD, was a rebel in his time, saying that God is available to everyone through their individual devotion. This tradition continues to this day. When I visited Udhav's village, I went to informal gatherings where these songs were sung in peoples' homes. And several times a year, people of the Varkari Samprodaya make long pilgrimages on foot, singing these songs and dancing for days. This is a living tradition which is to be enjoyed by all, without distinctions of high and low. My approach to these songs is to sing them as simply and purely as possible, more or less in a folk style. I don't try to imitate an Indian singer, and I certainly do not want to use a western classical technique in these songs.  I have performed them for audiences who know the tradition of Marathi bhajan, and they were delighted."
The biography also says she studies Dhrupad with two teachers. At “Kaise Jaina” for me her voice works best, because there she sings in a more Celtic way, which I think is the best compromise and idea, if you don’t have an Indian accent and voice. I really like the sax with the bass-like tabla (with accompanying droning tanpura). Especially “Dreamers and Wanderers” of 18’.53” is such a great example of what the trio capable of, instrumentally. (PS. From the 7 tracks 4 come with voice).

Info : www.udhavshinde.com & http://www.cdbaby.com/cd/udhavshinde
Daniel McBreathy webpages : http://danmcb.sdf-eu.org/sax/index.shtml
Info on the Indian percussion instrument pakhawaj : http://chandrakantha.com/articles/indian_music/pakhawaj.html & http://www.silverbushmusic.com/tablas.html & with sounds : http://www.framedrumming.com/pages/pak.html & http://www.pakhawaj.net/pages/731757/index.htm
Other Indian musical instruments : http://makar-records.com/siteus/frameinstrument.html
Heaven On Earth Music Terracotta (UK,2003)*°°'

Both musicians have worked together in London for about 25 years. John Altman arranged music before from Bjork, Tina Turner, Rod Stewart and George Michael. Craig Pruess is an American with residence in UK, worked with the East African Conservatoire in Kenya, with MIT in US, and has arranged records for Cliff Richard, and for Bollywood director Anu Malik, arranged Indo-Fusion tracks for Massive Attack and Bond and played sitar with Manic Street Preachers, Gareth Gates, and the Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra.

A reason why they were able to work with such big names possibly, one suspects is at least in the realm of technical perfection, and perhaps to give a recognisable or predictable character to an original sound.  Terracotta has such recognisable aspects and such an approach that a mainstream public would easily accept.

Although I’m highly sceptical about the use of keyboards, and to just anything that comes close to what sounds like sample-like effects, every element here is implied with such perfection in production, the few mainstream aspects are, within all variation, completely forgivable.

On the quietest first track, “Cantour”, the soprano sax and sitar with violin leads the melodic part. The rich sitar sound is performed with some echo and additional keyboards, which make this instrument sound more mellower as usual. In that way it makes the approach in this -still pleasant- track, closer to a more New Age Jazz Fusion style. But, as I mentioned before, this aspect that here and there is integrated into the complete music score, of such a more superficial mood inspiration, still is done in balance with all other aspects. There’s plenty of acoustic contribution that the whole score works pretty well, and might even becomes better with various listen.
It is especially after the second track, that the dynamic elements are building up. “Dance With Shiva” with some percussion in between Indian and North African, with the sarangi (an Indian violin-like instrument) and an Arab-like orchestra (conducted by D.P.Bannerjee, and played by the London Session Orchestra), combined with sitar and some soprano sax, is much more what I hoped to expect from a product which they themselves called “Indo African Jazz Fusion”, - a true original combination-. Also a track like “Massai Sonata” has African elements, greatly mixed in and produced, besides with sitar, with some African percussion & kalimba, and another good example of this fusion style. A couple of, mostly short, tracks in between are again closer to the more superficial synthesizer mood creations and inspirations, New Age documentary styled, with still good ideas, like on “Lover’s Kiss”, where we hear a good combination of keyboards with guitar keyboard, and with an attractive variety of percussion mixed in. These two tracks were used before for a film, released by channel 4 television, mastered by Keith Gould.
The filmic mood on the last series is slowly changed, from “Whispers”, into the final 16 minute track, showing the abilities of the duo to make their fusion style come another dynamic height, leaving the mainstream aspect in the background, with an Indian element (by Craig) as well as the jazz fusion element (by Altman) in its rightful place, combined with Indian Fusion violin and vocals (by Nawazish Ali Khan) and very dynamic percussion (by Khuljit Bhamra).

A good CD with good production, and with enough complexity making it possible that repeated listens are even more rewarding.

Info : http://www.heaven-on-earth-music.co.uk/hoemwebsite/prodcat/terra.html
Craig Pruess info : http://www.heaven-on-earth-music.co.uk/hoemwebsite/cpcv.html
Galloping Goat   Natraj : Deccan Dance (US,1998)**°

I think the approach of Natraj is very different from what we generally define under the term 'indo-jazz music'. They themselves describe it, on the cover of the CD, as “contemporary jazz with influences from India and Africa”. On "Kalyani" for instance, with a classical Indian tune as a source,even within the melody lines of it, the sax follows the jazz-mode too. Also the drum and bass solo is (contemporary) jazz instead. I would say this is an original approach. The electric violin, taking the melody line, “contemporary music like”, a half tone less, almost close to disharmony, still has a similar jazz approach touch. Second track then, "Na Yella Bo", plays a broody African bass line, as if playing an African instrument, combined with jazz improvisations with sax. After a while the percussion evolves to something I cannot place easily, as a different kind of fusion than I’m used too. Both "Raga Bihag, Part 1 - Vilambit" & "Raga Bihag, Part 2 - Drut" hereafter, are closest to the raga style, but the approach of the group, and especially the sax player shows his own jazz way of improvisation within the raga mode. Rhythmically, the tabla, bass, percussion just accompanies the sax improvisation quietly. From the last four tracks three of them are more jazz improvisations (basically with sax, bass, percussion, tabla). First track, "Don't Utter", by Maneri the violinist leading the improvisation first, in his strange style of playing, always a little bit lower than a normal harmony, and with some bass solo, played in a different, original way, somewhat comparable to the African touch he tried before. "Duet" shows within a recognisable elements new sounds and details. I especially I like the way the bass improvises here when the sax is leading. The "Introduction" to "Muhkhras not tukras" is somewhat exotic. The track itself, written by Scarff, the sax player, shows his improvisation skills once more, accompanied with very nice percussion and bass. Last track, "Blue Tumbleweed" concludes with another raga-like improvisation, in the sax player's own, specific, typical and in fact original jazz-way, with, once more, a violin improvisation played in the way I described before, and a bass solo with tabla and tampura. -All Indian flavoured tracks are of course also accompanied by tampura-.

In general I must say the group's approach to Indian music and to some African elements is really original. The rhythmical structure of Indian music is here a bit less important and is replaced by the jazz approach, which makes the group perhaps more unique in its kind.

More info : http://natraj.calabashmusic.com/ & http://www.windjam.com/artists/natraj/index.shtml & http://www.rambles.net/natraj_deccan.html & http://www.ashanet.org/nycnj/events/2003/Natraj/artists.html & http://www.bostonbands.com/band_layout2.asp?bid=358 or http://www.bostonbands.com/searchurl.asp?strurl=natraj
Other review of this album : http://www.allaboutjazz.com/reviews/r1299_170.htm & http://www.indianewengland.com/...
Newsgroup : http://launch.groups.yahoo.com/group/natraj/
More info on Michael Rivard : http://www.clubdelf.com/micro.html
More info on Mat Maneri : http://www.velocity.net/~bb10k/MANERI.disc.html
Dorian Disc.     Natraj : Meet me anywhere (US,1992)***°

For this release Natraj modestly describes the music here as “New Jazz and World Music”. The basic fundament is still jazz, of a wonderful and inspired kind, with openness to world music influences with perfect adaptations such as “Drop the Knife Twice”.

When listening for review purposes, I had to restart the CD a number of times, because I was completely drawn into it, so I could hardly keep myself at a distance, as a writer, trying to keep an overview of what is happening.

With three percussionists (one of them is African), and a bass player who has his African influences too, rhythmically it pulls you in so easily. Phil Scarf (sax), Mick Goodrick (guitar) and Steve Gorn (bamboo flute) found in that bop element a useful musical fundament for improvisation. Of course, the rhythms follow the improvisations too, are even stimulated by them, but basically are always like well balanced framing structures to anything what happens. "Resolution", a John Coltrane composition, is an Indian interpretation as intended by the sax player, and is also partly improvised on the bansuri flute played by Steve Gorn. “Meet me anywhere” has a somewhat unusual part, with a special minimal melodic rhythm repetition on tabla and another instrument I can not recall, in between distant piano and some string or plucked instrument.° It also has a small pure jazz part, besides the usual fusion jazz approach typical for Natraj.  "Avu Matodzo" is a West African traditional. Here Michael Rivard shows well his African-music influenced jazz bass. Phil Scarf knows how to improvise on sax on this style well too. Of course there’s more African percussion in this track as well. The last track, “Suite 203”, is a more meditative Indian styled piece, which fits perfectly as a closer for the album. A perfect listen. Recommended !

Info : http://natraj.calabashmusic.com/ & http://calabashmusic.com/world/?pop=3130&artist=1
Steve Gorn's (bamboo player's) entry : http://www.stevegorn.com/recordings/meetme.php

JPC entry (with audio) http://www.jpc.de/jpcdb/f...
Amazon entry (with audio) : http://www.amazon.de/exec/..
Best-buy entry (with audio) : http://www.bestbuy.com/...
Artist-direct (with audio) : http://www.artistdirect.com/..
label sales entry : http://www.dorian.com/store/main.mvc?...
Distributor sales entry : http://www.windjamrecords.bigstep.com/...

° I asked in a mail what it was. This is what Phil Scarff answered : "In his tabla solo on the title track, Meet Me Anywhere, Jerry plays the large table (bayan) upside down, such that he is striking the metallic bowl of the drum, instead of the skin (head). The sound is reminiscent of the South Indian clay drum (ghatam). The accompaniment is by bass and guitar playing harmonics."

A small percussion part of this album is used on a world percussion compilation album : http://www.rhombuspublishing.com/music.html
GO TO NEXT REVIEW PAGE->
INDOJAZZ-FUSION
The Udhav Shinde Trio

CD (2003)

go back to the previous review page
or go back to the
sitar / India crossovers index
or go back to the main index